MPs back Dieppe sign fight

Published Saturday June 27th, 2009

Law student pushing Dieppe city council for bilingualism bylaw for business signs

A1

Efforts to force Dieppe businesses to include French and English on all their interior and exterior signage, by way of a municipal bylaw, won the support of two federal politicians yesterday.

Brian Murphy, Liberal MP for Moncton-Riverview-Dieppe, and Yvon Godin, New Democrat MP for Acadie-Bathurst, have both endorsed Martin LeBlanc-Rioux, a McGill University law student from Dieppe, in his continuing bid to get city council to adopt a city language bylaw.

LeBlanc-Rioux started the process last fall and in January presented a petition to council with 4,016 names supporting a bylaw. At the time, city council was non-committal on what to do with the petition but said they'd study the proposal.

LeBlanc-Rioux said he's trying to make sure French is kept prominent in Dieppe -- a city which tags itself as the Acadian capital of the world.

Dieppe businesses with interior French or bilingual signage were recorded at 39 per cent in 2005, growing to 73 per cent in 2007. With exterior signs, the number went from 45 per cent in 2005 to 72 per cent in 2007.

LeBlanc-Rioux said a language bylaw would force national chain stores, which might not respect or recognize Dieppe's demographics, to abide by rules.

Murphy and Godin said they hoped their added voices would encourage councillors to speed up the process of making a decision.

"Dieppe could be the example for the province," said Godin, suggesting the city could serve as an example to other cities and towns in the New Brunswick -- Canada's only officially bilingual province.

Moncton -- Canada's only officially bilingual city -- has 80 per cent of its business signs in English only, with two per cent in French only and 18 per cent in both official languages, according to the findings of the New Brunswick Council on French Language Planning.

Murphy, a former mayor of Moncton, said Dieppe could be an example to the city next door.

"Maybe it's something that the City of Moncton will think in its wisdom is a very positive thing," he said.

Murphy said New Brunswick's French-speaking community has waited long enough to see language equality exhibited in the front windows of businesses, and not just on the written papers of laws, bills and motions.

"It leaves open whether there should be a renewal of provincial policies with respect to official bilingualism," said Murphy.

Both Murphy and Godin brushed off suggestions the provincial or federal governments would intervene in forcing a language bylaw on municipalities.

However, they're still calling on Dieppe to lead the way.

Calls made to Dieppe city hall yesterday were not returned.

LeBlanc-Rioux said he was confident the city was taking his proposal seriously, but hoped for an answer sooner rather than later.

"I didn't want a doctor's thesis," he said. "I wanted a bylaw."

 

Disabled

Commenting has been disabled for this item. Existing comments appear below but you may not add a new comment at this time.

Comments (60)

All comments are subject to the site Terms of Use. For a full commenting tutorial click here.

Our editorial team relies on filtering technology and our visitor community to identify inappropriate comments. In the event that a site user has submitted offensive content that has evaded our filter, please select the option to Flag As Inappropriate presented within the comment. Thank you for helping to keep this site clean.

"whether there should be a renewal of provincial policies with respect to official bilingualism, said Murphy." Yes there should be a renewal of policies if the government is going to continue calling this a bilingual province. The original act has served its purpose regarding respect and representation for the French language. Now the act needs to protect the rights of English only citizens. Especially if govt is going to continue to increase the number of jobs requiring bilingualism as the number of French only citizens decreases. All children should have access to the French schools and an immersion kindergarten to prepare them for Grade 1.

In some areas Francophone parents have to prevent their children from using English too much. This is a confusing issue. Maybe it is time for the govt to do as all govt's do -stay out of language issues and let the cards fall where they may. Where numbers warrant citizens would be served by neighboring citizens with similar capabilities. Voila.
75
Thumbs Up
11
Thumbs Down
Well-fed Mushroom, N.B. on 27/06/09 06:57:28 AM AST
The only country I know of that forces signs to be a certain language is North Korea where they stopped using Chinese characters and are only allowed to use Hangeul, the Korean alphabet. In addition, they can only use state sponsored words, as many South Korean words have been polluted by other languages (loan words, like AISU KURIM, or ice cream). A law forcing language is a very bad idea.
109
Thumbs Up
12
Thumbs Down
Doesn't Matter, Moncton on 27/06/09 07:44:09 AM AST
Giving a thumbs down means you have no argument valid enough to stand on it's own.
23
Thumbs Up
41
Thumbs Down
Doesn't Matter, Moncton on 27/06/09 07:58:24 AM AST
On another note, if Dieppe was truly bilingual, it would have no need for the law, because everyone could read a sign whether in English or French. I'm sick of the language issue, and more and more English are getting sick of it too. Understand one thing, English is the majority in this province (and the world!) and if you push too far, you might just start losing out when the majority votes to tell you to shove it Acadia!
107
Thumbs Up
23
Thumbs Down
Doesn't Matter, Moncton on 27/06/09 08:01:07 AM AST
So with a language bylaw, then the Codiac RCMP would become a "language police"? Funny how, the Federals need to get involved, does that mean that this idea has little merit on it's own. If a run a national chain store, do I locate where I have to go to the extra expense of a special sign to serve a few thousand people or do I locate on the other side of the city line? Not well thought out for sure!
87
Thumbs Up
7
Thumbs Down
D W, Fredericton on 27/06/09 08:43:50 AM AST
This is getting very scary to me. To have yet another right taken away from us is going too far. Each week it seems we are forced into the governments totalaristic ways. We've lost a lot of freedom over the years, just think of where we'll be going down this path in another 25-50 years..... very scary.

On this issue alone though, its unfortunate that some people are unable to use that power of choice we are supposed to use. If you don't like what you see in a place of establishment ie: Products, prices, service, signage, then simply leave! LEAVE! Do not support that business! Simple as that, don't go sulking to the government that someone else's business doesn't meet your standards.
91
Thumbs Up
9
Thumbs Down
777 777, Riverview on 27/06/09 09:16:44 AM AST
This comment has been removed due to a violation of canadaeast.com's Terms of Use, Section F. Interactive Features. Click here to review the Terms of Use.
b. riverdance, moncton on 27/06/09 10:16:09 AM AST
Wow, what a surprise another language debate!!!!

Signage language should be up to the owner's discretion, if an owner of a business has a clever logo designed with whichever language he choses, why should he/she be forced to pay to have his/her sign redesigned.

B.Riverdance and Don white how about contributing to a solution instead of just making ignorant comments!
17
Thumbs Up
43
Thumbs Down
Notig norant, moncton on 27/06/09 10:37:21 AM AST
Acadians have 38 Acadian Societys in New Brunswick that are funded with English speaking tax dollars.

There is only a few Anglophone Societys in NB and we are the majority.

The Anglophone Society is thinking of starting a chapter here in Moncton.
64
Thumbs Up
12
Thumbs Down
b. riverdance, moncton on 27/06/09 10:37:50 AM AST
Riverdance, you seem to have a big problem with the French and with situations like these, the recent education decisions and more I kinda don't blame you but calling out Quebec policies your missing the overall picture that you should be putting the blame on, this is a case of loosing freedom more than it is French vs English ( which our government loves to see ). Like I said before, we must fight for our freedom of choice, write your government representatives.

The insanity ends when we get rid of these two governments (liberal and PC), then and only then can we work towards a real change.
19
Thumbs Up
31
Thumbs Down
777 777, Riverview on 27/06/09 10:40:32 AM AST
Advertisement
Advertisement

Search Articles