MPs back Dieppe sign fight

Published Saturday June 27th, 2009

Law student pushing Dieppe city council for bilingualism bylaw for business signs

A1

Efforts to force Dieppe businesses to include French and English on all their interior and exterior signage, by way of a municipal bylaw, won the support of two federal politicians yesterday.

Brian Murphy, Liberal MP for Moncton-Riverview-Dieppe, and Yvon Godin, New Democrat MP for Acadie-Bathurst, have both endorsed Martin LeBlanc-Rioux, a McGill University law student from Dieppe, in his continuing bid to get city council to adopt a city language bylaw.

LeBlanc-Rioux started the process last fall and in January presented a petition to council with 4,016 names supporting a bylaw. At the time, city council was non-committal on what to do with the petition but said they'd study the proposal.

LeBlanc-Rioux said he's trying to make sure French is kept prominent in Dieppe -- a city which tags itself as the Acadian capital of the world.

Dieppe businesses with interior French or bilingual signage were recorded at 39 per cent in 2005, growing to 73 per cent in 2007. With exterior signs, the number went from 45 per cent in 2005 to 72 per cent in 2007.

LeBlanc-Rioux said a language bylaw would force national chain stores, which might not respect or recognize Dieppe's demographics, to abide by rules.

Murphy and Godin said they hoped their added voices would encourage councillors to speed up the process of making a decision.

"Dieppe could be the example for the province," said Godin, suggesting the city could serve as an example to other cities and towns in the New Brunswick -- Canada's only officially bilingual province.

Moncton -- Canada's only officially bilingual city -- has 80 per cent of its business signs in English only, with two per cent in French only and 18 per cent in both official languages, according to the findings of the New Brunswick Council on French Language Planning.

Murphy, a former mayor of Moncton, said Dieppe could be an example to the city next door.

"Maybe it's something that the City of Moncton will think in its wisdom is a very positive thing," he said.

Murphy said New Brunswick's French-speaking community has waited long enough to see language equality exhibited in the front windows of businesses, and not just on the written papers of laws, bills and motions.

"It leaves open whether there should be a renewal of provincial policies with respect to official bilingualism," said Murphy.

Both Murphy and Godin brushed off suggestions the provincial or federal governments would intervene in forcing a language bylaw on municipalities.

However, they're still calling on Dieppe to lead the way.

Calls made to Dieppe city hall yesterday were not returned.

LeBlanc-Rioux said he was confident the city was taking his proposal seriously, but hoped for an answer sooner rather than later.

"I didn't want a doctor's thesis," he said. "I wanted a bylaw."

 

Disabled

Commenting has been disabled for this item. Existing comments appear below but you may not add a new comment at this time.

Comments (60)

All comments are subject to the site Terms of Use. For a full commenting tutorial click here.

Our editorial team relies on filtering technology and our visitor community to identify inappropriate comments. In the event that a site user has submitted offensive content that has evaded our filter, please select the option to Flag As Inappropriate presented within the comment. Thank you for helping to keep this site clean.

There is evidence of a "Quebec agenda" in this petition. LeBlanc-Rioux's original petition, and I don't know if he has revised it, called for signage to be bilingual or only French. There are Dieppe citizens that have only English skills . Also there are French speaking citizens who cannot read French and/or prefer to read English.

To get some 4000 signatures he must have found every native Quebecer living in Dieppe and some of the few Acadians still carrying the torch of revenge against the sins of our forefathers. All of the Acadians I know say they feel that Quebec has no more respect for their culture then they do for any English based cultures.

Dieppe city council didn't jump on the idea. That should be enough to indicate to these Federal ministers that it is a city issue, not even provincial, and they have no business giving an opinion. I'm sure there is more important federal problems that could use some attention.
40
Thumbs Up
3
Thumbs Down
Two Steps Behind, N.B. on 27/06/09 06:06:33 PM AST

People shop where it is convenient and where they can get the products and services they want. Regardless of the signage in Dieppe I will shop in Moncton North - unless they relocate Dieppe or I move, that will not change - I could care less what language is on the sign.

The gov't has better things to do with taxpayers money then police signage, like improving healthcare and education for starters.
37
Thumbs Up
2
Thumbs Down
Rao B, Anywhere on 27/06/09 08:19:33 PM AST
Re: comments being removed ... I too have had comments removed. When I asked Canadaeast why, twice by the way, they never replied. None of my comments were racist or discriminatory. They were simply my opinions and provided information, quotes, etc. Funny how most of the time the comments that are removed are from those, like myself, who are against official (forced) bilingualism. I have noticed in the past few months more and more people are finally opening their eyes to the farce of bilingualism. It's about time. People are finally realizing that bilingualism only benefits Francophones. It enables them to continue to speak their own language while forcing, yes forcing, Anglophones to speak French. What about Anglophones' rights to speak their own language. We are the majority afterall. Let's start acting like it and exert our majority power.
33
Thumbs Up
8
Thumbs Down
2 cents worth, moncton on 27/06/09 09:49:35 PM AST
This comment has been removed due to a violation of canadaeast.com's Terms of Use, Section F. Interactive Features. Click here to review the Terms of Use.
2 cents worth, moncton on 27/06/09 09:53:03 PM AST
I've got to start copying and pasting some of these comments before they get removed.

Why was my comment removed where I stated that Quebec has an agenda... To take over the Maritimes just as they did Quebec? To rid the Maritimes of all Anglophones, With every English speaking person that leaves the maritimes there is a Francophone from Quebec to come here and take their place.

If the Acadians think they are secure they are wrong.

Quebec has helped you get where you are today... You enjoy the good wages and perks of the provincial, county and municipal jobs while Anlophones are lucky to have a job flipping burgers at a fast food joint.

Quebec will expect a payment in return... For Acadians To give up their culture and for you to learn "Proper French."

There copied and pasted and if removed there will be other places to post it that allow ones freedom of speech and expression such as Freecycle and Kijiji.

More people access these sites than the they do the T&T.

30
Thumbs Up
5
Thumbs Down
b. riverdance, moncton on 27/06/09 11:14:57 PM AST
Respect=recognition! As a francophone from Ontario, I am proud of Mr. Rioux's intiatives, as I feel it is a positive step in the recognition of our country's bilingual character. I sincerely hope to see similar moves in other parts of the country as well, including my home town of Sudbury.

As Queen Latifah would say, 'all y'all better recognize and start respectin'!'

7
Thumbs Up
41
Thumbs Down
J L, Sudbury, ON on 27/06/09 11:28:03 PM AST
Gee, if they want a bilingual sign around here they would have to put one up like. Tim Horton's Donuts et Coffee. No one in Dieppe that I know of speaks pure french. It's mixed in with English. I once heard someone say "Je parker mon char dans la parking lot la!" Bilingualism is a joke! It really and truly only benefits the French. If you go to the mall you get served in French, if you go to government buildings, you get served in French! It's ridiculous! I mean honestly do you have to be bilingual to clean toilets somewhere? Are the toilets going to suddenly speak to you in French? I am so tired of the whole language thing, why don't we all just speak the language that we speak. Besides that, if we really need to learn a new language it should be that of the Native tongue. They were here long before French or English!
33
Thumbs Up
8
Thumbs Down
Tracy Lapointe, Riverview on 28/06/09 12:14:15 AM AST
Some myth busting is due: You need to be francophone or bilingual to get a decent job... false. Try finding a decent job in the Southeast if you are unilingual French... impossible. Try to find one if you're unilingual English... happens all the time. That's a reality most Acadians can live with and do because most of us are indeed bilingual and we understand the weight of demographics.

Another myth that seems just as near sighted: somehow, for some, it doesn't seem fair that Francophone rights group are bigger and better funded than Anglophone rights group. Reality is that Anglophones form the majority in New Brunswick as well as the GMA. As a majority, and we live in a democracy, all governments, national, provincial and municipal, in the case of Moncton and Riverview, are creatures of the Anglophone majority and way more influent and funded than any Francophone rights group will ever be.

Minorities do need some protection and promotion just to survive. That's the general idea.
9
Thumbs Up
31
Thumbs Down
Anonymous Reader, Fredericton on 28/06/09 08:54:38 AM AST
A study conducted in 2007 by scientists at the Rotman Research Institute in Toronto has found evidence that speaking two languages throughout one's life appears to be associated with a delay in the onset of symptoms of dementia by four years compared to those who speak one language. Other studies have proven that bilinguals are better at IQ tests than monolinguals. Being bilingual has a positive effect on intellectual growth and enriches a person’s mental development. Bilingualism helps improve our way of thinking and behaving and also enhances our self-esteem. It also gives a deeper knowledge of different ideas and opens the door to other cultures and traditions. All these benefits would be available to Anglophones if they would embrace the idea of learning French instead of finding ways to criticize it.
9
Thumbs Up
30
Thumbs Down
M. Cormier, Dieppe on 28/06/09 09:00:19 AM AST
Learning a language is a skill, not one everyone has M. Cormier. I have it and speak 5 languages, and I was lucky because being in immersion and learning French early absolutely helped me when I learned my other languages. Not everyone is as lucky with language though. If you asked me to paint a picture, there would be 3 year olds who could do better with a crayon and a napkin than I could :) This is one point that is never brought up.

I don't think most of the people here are anti-French or anti-bilingual (which doesn't have to mean French/English either), they are just sick of hearing about Acadia and French (having it shoved down their throats) and the glaring inequality of the two language cultures. The problem is, the more I read these forums and every time I come back to Moncton, I see that frustration turning into anger which is not good. Like I said before, Acadia and the French hardcore people better start laying off before they realize that the majority is English!
32
Thumbs Up
9
Thumbs Down
Doesn't Matter, Moncton on 28/06/09 09:10:38 AM AST
Advertisement
Advertisement

Search Articles