Docs sue N.B. over wage freeze

Published Friday July 3rd, 2009

Province, medical society to meet in court Aug. 6

A1

FREDERICTON - New Brunswick's doctors have launched legal action against the provincial government over the two-year wage freeze announced by the Liberals earlier this year.

Dr. Ludger Blier, president of the New Brunswick Medical Society, said both groups will meet in court on Aug. 6 in Saint John.

"We spent many days, weeks and months negotiating agreements on behalf of fee-for-service and salaried physicians that were signed off by both parties, the Medical Society and government," he said in a statement.

"Our members subsequently ratified the terms of the agreements and trusted the Shawn Graham government to live up to the commitment they made to New Brunswick physicians. It is clear to us now that our trust was misplaced.

"It is deeply regrettable that New Brunswick physicians are being forced to turn to the courts in an effort to salvage agreements that were negotiated in good faith."

A Health Department spokeswoman said Health Minister Mary Schryer is refusing to comment because the matter is before the courts.

The provincial government's response to the court action will be determined by Attorney General Mike Murphy, who served as the Liberal health minister when the wage dispute began.

The province's doctors threatened court action after the provincial government refused to honour a tentative agreement that would have given physicians a 3.75 per cent annual wage increase over the life of a four-year contract.

The province's fee-for-service doctors reached a tentative agreement with the provincial government in December. The physicians ratified the deal but government refused to sign the contract, saying it was too expensive given the economic situation.

The Liberals then introduced legislation to freeze physicians' wages for two years.

The legislation passed but has not yet been proclaimed into law.

All other public sector employees will also have their wages frozen for two years.

Murphy has said agreeing to the first two years of the tentative agreement would have cost the province roughly $36 million and warned government would be forced to close hospitals or community health centres as a result.

Because the doctors have been without a contract since last April, the doctors would have to go to April 2010 without a salary increase in order to fulfill the two-year wage freeze.

The doctors have said patients won't be impacted by their fight with the government.

However, Blier said the fight could impact government's effort to recruit physicians.

"Every other province in the country is recruiting and New Brunswick is the only province that has chosen to treat its doctors that way," he said.

Opposition leader David Alward said the premier should be making more of an effort to reach out to the province's doctors.

"It sends a very poor message that this government is not open for business when it comes to recruiting and wanting to keep our doctors," he said. "Our doctors are the most important asset that we have as a province."

 

Disabled

Commenting has been disabled for this item. Existing comments appear below but you may not add a new comment at this time.

Comments (11)

All comments are subject to the site Terms of Use. For a full commenting tutorial click here.

Our editorial team relies on filtering technology and our visitor community to identify inappropriate comments. In the event that a site user has submitted offensive content that has evaded our filter, please select the option to Flag As Inappropriate presented within the comment. Thank you for helping to keep this site clean.

Your group ratified, fine, but the government did not ratify it, so quite whining!
1
Thumbs Up
18
Thumbs Down
Harry Balzac, Moncton on 03/07/09 08:00:06 AM AST
what happened is called BREACH OF CONTRACT. Plain and simple in legal terms. It is not whining. It is how all contracts with government are negotiated. You would not be so cocky if it had happened to you.
13
Thumbs Up
2
Thumbs Down
Rob Sense, SJ on 03/07/09 08:07:22 AM AST
HB, the Gov't presented the 'numbers' to the Doctors, numbers which the Gov't was happy and willing to give otherwise they would not have presented them to the Doctors!!

The Gov't negotiating team wouldn't have put those 'numbers' before any group without the approval of Gov't financial ministers in the first place.

I wonder if the Gov't is enforcing the 'language' of the contract in all other aspects other than the dollars?

Just a major act of deceit on the part of Murphy, Boudreau, Graham!!

12
Thumbs Up
1
Thumbs Down
T. Wright, Greater Moncton on 03/07/09 08:13:23 AM AST
THe Liberals lied to the entire population regarding HST energy rebates (among other things) so the doctors should not be surprised........
12
Thumbs Up
1
Thumbs Down
joe blow, moncton on 03/07/09 08:27:50 AM AST
How can you legislate that somebody can't sue you? That in itself should be grounds for ANOTHER constitutional challenge. Or is that their plan? To tie this up in the courts until a new contract is required (2012?).
7
Thumbs Up
1
Thumbs Down
JustRight OfCenter, Fredericton area on 03/07/09 08:32:23 AM AST
The Goverment can't seem to find money to pay for what WE need the most like doctors, health care and education,but they can find many millions to feed an unstable companie to which we'll probably have to dish out that loan ourselves with stupid taxes.
0
Thumbs Up
0
Thumbs Down
s. king, Ca on 03/07/09 10:24:31 AM AST
What an example of greed, selfishness and egoism the doctors are giving to their children. All other government groups have their wages frozen and they are not suing the government. Only the doctors, amongst the highest income earners in the province, are pushing their greed to that extent. They should be very ashamed of themselves.
0
Thumbs Up
0
Thumbs Down
J. R, Moncton, NB on 03/07/09 11:36:26 AM AST
This isn't a case of greed.. it's a challenge to a bunch of "out of touch with reality" politicians that can spend millions on bankrupt credit unions, soon to be bankrupt construction companies and best of all, spend millions so far on pouring rock into the Petitcodiac River to be washed down stream next spring.The same politicians break promises to the voters of New Brunswick, cut school bus service, close libraries and continue to diminish the basic services we as taxpayers are entitled to.

There is money to support the friends of the government but we can't get our roads repaired, we have to wait hours forservices at the hospitals, we need to pay for the ambulance to get us there and if those fools have their way, there will be NO doctors to greet and care for us at the hospitals.

No this isn't greed.. this is a group of fair and responsible professionals standing up for what we all need to stand for,fair and responsible government, not what we are getting now!!!
0
Thumbs Up
0
Thumbs Down
J. Wortman, Moncton on 03/07/09 07:00:57 PM AST
Please, Mr. Premier, put us out of our collective misery and call an election!
0
Thumbs Up
0
Thumbs Down
Rao B, Anywhere on 04/07/09 01:46:20 AM AST
JR. Greed? Selfishness? Egoism? WHO is paying you to say those things? We all know who you work for. Did you take a wage freeze from the gravy train?
0
Thumbs Up
0
Thumbs Down
Rob Sense, SJ on 04/07/09 09:33:20 AM AST
Advertisement
Advertisement

Search Articles