Stay calm during pandemic: expert

Published Monday November 9th, 2009

N.B. pandemic history professor says we're following the

A1

While there are certain unknowns about how the H1N1 pandemic will play out in the weeks and months to come, people can take comfort in knowing one thing, according to a New Brunswick expert in pandemic disease history.

A look back at past pandemics suggests that life goes on both during and after such an event. And as far as diseases go, today's H1N1 flu is following to a tee the model of past pandemics, says Dr. Jane Jenkins, who teaches a class called History of Disease at Fredericton's St. Thomas University.

"I think what we're seeing now with H1N1 is a classic example of the psychological impact that pandemics have on people," she said.

Jenkins said it's typical during pandemics for people to bounce back and forth between the two extremes of having a nonchalant attitude and having all-out panic. That has been the case with H1N1 since the virus' outbreak began last April.

Right now, Jenkins said fear of H1N1 is at what she'd consider a high level.

Back when reports of unusual flu activity began to surface in Mexico last spring (when it was better known as swine flu), Jenkins said fear was also high in the general population which is common when most novel flu strains are in their infancy.

"And then we were told everything was going to be okay, that government was in control and that Canada was one of the few countries in the world to have vaccinations for everyone," said Jenkins. "And then there was some complacency I think that set in, and people were saying 'it's just the flu' and 'just a couple of days of being sick.'"

In early October, a poll suggested that only a third of Canadians would get the H1N1 flu shot when it became available, compared to 45 per cent in late August.

But later in October, news broke that a healthy, athletic Ontario teen died from H1N1. That news sent shockwaves of panic across the country. And it all happened at time when H1N1 flu shot clinics were being cancelled and rescheduled because lesser than expected vaccine amounts were being manufactured.

Jenkins said it's normal that a young person dying from H1N1 would cause a shift in attitudes from apathy to hysteria, especially in 2009. She said that might not have been the case during an event like the 1918-1919 pandemic (commonly referred to as the Spanish flu), because deaths of young people from disease were more common at that time than today.

While any such news is concerning, Jenkins said history has taught us that the best and most beneficial attitude to have during any pandemic situation is one that's split between caution and calm.

"People have been told this is a dangerous virus and we've been told this by experts in their fields," she said. "The trick for government officials and public health officials is to find a way to balance the legitimate awareness of risk with a calming influence of trying to convey to people that there are resources available."

"That's the trick."

And an understanding of what the word 'pandemic' means can also help.

In June, when the World Health Organization announced H1N1 as the world's first official flu pandemic in 41 years, they said the designation had more to do with the virus' spread country-to-country and not that the virus had become more dangerous or aggressive.

All along, health officials have said they're concerned about the pandemic H1N1 flu strain because most people don't have immunity, and because it's targeting mostly young people -- an age group not considered to be at high risk of getting hit by typical seasonal flu.

 

Disabled

Commenting has been disabled for this item. Existing comments appear below but you may not add a new comment at this time.

Comments (8)

All comments are subject to the site Terms of Use. For a full commenting tutorial click here.

Our editorial team relies on filtering technology and our visitor community to identify inappropriate comments. In the event that a site user has submitted offensive content that has evaded our filter, please select the option to Flag As Inappropriate presented within the comment. Thank you for helping to keep this site clean.

If the mental midgets at public health would let family physicians give the swine flu shot to their patients as they do the seasonal flu, then maybe we couldn't have so much confusion and line ups at vaccination clinics.
16
Thumbs Up
2
Thumbs Down
monkey towner, moncton on 09/11/09 08:49:52 AM AST
"I think what we're seeing now with H1N1 is a classic example of the psychological impact that pandemics have on people,"

Only on the sheep of society.
There are still some of us who prefer to think for ourselves.
Educate yourselves people, don't always believe the worst case scenario the government throws our way.
17
Thumbs Up
1
Thumbs Down
J B, Riverview on 09/11/09 10:23:31 AM AST
Ok, so, here is an idea - close the schools down for 2 weeks giving assignments to students to occupy their time. Ask that everyone stay close to home and perfect the art of coughing or sneezing into the elbow. Also perfect the art of proper mask wearing (cover the nose too!!)... We all know that flus go through schools like wildfire, in turn the germs come home to parents and parents go to work and do errands...etc.etc.etc...

So, hand-washing is a given but so is proper rest, diet and taking Vitamin D, C, B complex, etc, especially in the winter.

What I can't understand is why they are stating that that there are only 30 something confirmed cases in Moncton when there are at least that many from one school alone??? I was told that a doctor stated to a parent (after her child was positively diagnosed last week for H1N1) that the schools aren't doing much - in regard to shutting down to quash this thing....in fact, I believe that the woman asked for a note to give to .....

4
Thumbs Up
3
Thumbs Down
Cal I., Moncton on 09/11/09 02:21:42 PM AST
.... school to explain that her child had H1N1 and to advise that there was a confirmed case in the school and the doctor's remark was " they don't give a damn"....

WELL... If I was the School District administrator, I would think that closing schools for 2 weeks would make an awful lot of sense!!!! Seeing that H1N1 has a one week incubation period (so they say) wouldn't this put the brakes on this wave of infection??

Makes you wonder, huh??

4
Thumbs Up
2
Thumbs Down
Cal Ingersoll, Moncton on 09/11/09 02:27:46 PM AST
Well closing the schools for 2 weeks, they would have to make that up at the end of the school year, heaven forbid if might cut into summer vacation..
3
Thumbs Up
0
Thumbs Down
seeing whatsup, Moncton on 09/11/09 07:14:03 PM AST
monkey towner, regular gp's don't have the vaccine because of its short shelf life.

JB, give up already, nobody is listening to you anymore!
1
Thumbs Up
2
Thumbs Down
pumakin pumakin, moncton on 09/11/09 08:27:58 PM AST
Oh yes, I forgot to mention that the child mentioned in my above comments got his H1N1 shot weeks before he got sick with H1N1...


hmmmm?????

2
Thumbs Up
0
Thumbs Down
Cal Ingersoll, Moncton on 09/11/09 08:32:14 PM AST
The only pandemic is the media and Health Canada hype!!!!
0
Thumbs Up
0
Thumbs Down
Laurie Clark, Dieppe on 11/11/09 12:08:28 AM AST
Advertisement
Advertisement

Search Articles