NB Power sale lifts big burden

Published Friday October 30th, 2009
D10

The details of the Memorandum of Agreement to sell NB Power to Quebec Hydro are now public, revealing a positive deal that will stand all New Brunswickers in good stead for years to come.

The agreement reduces the provincial debt by about 40 per cent ($4.75 billion), money that every citizen and taxpayer, today and in future, would have had to eventually pay, plus considerable interest. It is the equivalent of more than $6,300 for every man, woman and child in the province. That alone makes it an attractive deal. It will also benefit the province via better credit ratings.

NB Power rates have soared over the past several years and citizens were looking at the prospect of increases of at least three per cent per year (and possibly more) for many years to come. This deal freezes residential power rates for five years, a saving of hundreds of dollars per household through to 2015. Industrial users of power will see rate declines to Quebec's low levels, something that is virtually certain to create jobs and new industry here -- it makes New Brunswick one of the most attractive places on the continent to invest since power rates are a large part of any industry's costs.

The agreement states Hydro Quebec will hire all NB Power employees and honour collective agreements. The public has long complained of the NB Power bureaucracy and its bonuses. This deal removes that drain on our public purse.

Premier Graham is promising a full public and Legislature debate, as he must, and there are undoubtedly some questions to which the answers are not immediately obvious. Yet Quebec is paying fair market value for NB Power's assets and it is agreeing to a regulatory framework to be put in place to ensure ratepayers are protected. The PUB will continue to have to approve any rate hikes in future, just as it does today. The deal does not remove energy policy from the government's hands.

We do urge Quebec Hydro to continue along the environmentally green path we've begun travelling with wind farms and further development of alternative sources. It only makes sense for the future. That said, we see no reason why it would not, given that it is already doing so in Quebec.

Premier Graham merits credit for reaching a forward-looking, positive deal and recognizing the opportunity when it arose. As he noted, former premier Frank McKenna set the ball rolling towards a NB Power sale, and former premier Bernard Lord laid the groundwork and sought buyers. There are benefits for Quebec Hydro as well, but that should not surprise anyone: if there were not fair benefits for both sides, no deal would be reached.

 

Comments (20)

All comments are subject to the site Terms of Use. For a full commenting tutorial click here.

Our editorial team relies on filtering technology and our visitor community to identify inappropriate comments. In the event that a site user has submitted offensive content that has evaded our filter, please select the option to Flag As Inappropriate presented within the comment. Thank you for helping to keep this site clean.

Hmmm, why does this commentary not surprise me in the least? I respect every person's right to express their opinion just as much as I respect an editor's unbiased opinion. To me however, this article seems a little tilted - perhaps it is the influence of the ownership, who knows. However, whatever way big business, the government, and even these narrow-minded and near-sighted individuals try to spin it, the fact is New Brunswick, we will surely lose a tremendous asset which we will never recover. Further, when 5 years have passed, I would like for all of us to think back to this day and wonder the following: are we better off? Are the committments that were agreed upon still in place? Where is Mr. Graham and how did this deal affect him? I bet the answers will not be too surprising! Mark my words...we will be left in the cold. Hydro Quebec will be laughing at us and Mr. Graham and his cronies will surely be laughing too!
47
Thumbs Up
11
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Justa Thought, Moncton on 30/10/09 08:17:29 AM AST
Selling NBPower to Quebec to pay the province's deficit is like a parent selling one of their kid to help pay the mortgage. Somethings are just wrong in every sense. Another mess by the Liberals. QH is in the service and profit business. Who do you think is going to pay for NB's operation cost in NB after five years?
46
Thumbs Up
8
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
B. C, Dieppe on 30/10/09 08:31:09 AM AST
If I were to sell my house tomorrow, would I sell it for the market value, or would I sell it for just enough to pay off the remaining balance on my mortgage?

Selling NB power for $4.8 billion (which is just enough to pay off its debt) is exactly like selling off a house just to cover what's left on the mortgage. It also means that you're essentially taking a loss, because the balance owing is always lower than the market value of the property.

Nice to see the Times and Transcript is still faithful to its Irving masters.
42
Thumbs Up
9
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
cbm cbm, dieppe on 30/10/09 08:56:04 AM AST
Hum, saving money for the rest of my life or paying a debt that was started under the HATFIELD Gov because of NBPower's mismanagement...Just a Thought.

Not one of the Atlantic Province's Utility is owned by their respective governments. In the 3 other jurisdictions, their are privatized...at least here, it will still be under a public entity and we all know that power is regulated, so I have no worries.

Cheers to the Graham Government...
11
Thumbs Up
35
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Dr. No., Moncton on 30/10/09 09:41:46 AM AST
An NB Power employee writes, " ...Selling NB power for $4.8 billion (which is just enough to pay off its debt) is exactly like selling off a house just to cover what's left on the mortgage."

I don't know who has a $4,800,000,000.00 mortage left on their house. But whoever they are they are irresponsible leaving future generations with a crippling burden to make the debt payments.
The "house" is on now the market because of location,location,location.

Sell Sell Sell!
10
Thumbs Up
37
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Peter Winchcombe, Essex on 30/10/09 09:51:20 AM AST
Peter Winchcombe:

I didn't say not to sell. I'm actually of the opinion that they probably could have gotten more money for it. How much would it cost to build the power infrastructure from scratch? More than $5 billion, I'm certain.

Hydro Quebec got an absolute bargain.

And no, I'm not an NB Power employee -- just a taxpayer.
29
Thumbs Up
4
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
cbm cbm, dieppe on 30/10/09 11:03:43 AM AST
Companies have debt, it is a way to finance business. Is NB Power's too high? Probably yes, but Quebec Hydro doesn't seem to have a problem taking it on in exchange for the assets. NS, PEI, NFLD, and Quebec all want NB's distribution network. It seems that there may be more value, and long term debt releif, in operating the networks itself, then selling off the top assets, and receiving nothing from the long term benifits.
8
Thumbs Up
10
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
JOHNNY QUINN, MONCTON on 30/10/09 11:12:25 AM AST
This comment has been removed due to a violation of canadaeast.com's Terms of Use, Section F. Interactive Features. Click here to review the Terms of Use.
M C Blais, Moncton on 30/10/09 11:41:13 AM AST
This comment has been removed due to a violation of canadaeast.com's Terms of Use, Section F. Interactive Features. Click here to review the Terms of Use.
cbm cbm, dieppe on 30/10/09 11:46:15 AM AST
It is quite clear that you don't have any understanding of the deal. First the lower industrial rates are only for heritage industrial companies....not new companies. Secondly your power rates are based on paying down the debt. It is not the tax payer but the rate payer, so with this said HQ freeze the rates for 5 years and then get CPI plus increases forever! I would also like to know what your background is to make a statement that they paid "Fair Market Value"? What is the value of a completely re-fubrished Nuclear Plant....new is 5 - 8 Billion? As HQ only pay for and take over the up and running Pt. Lepreau... risk free to HQ. Now what is the fair market value of a hydro system??? ansd last but certainly not least the Transmission system, which have a guaranteed rate of return of 10%....and this is just the start....no room here for more....just a question who do you work for and who stands to gain the most?? IRVING!!!!!!!!!!!
21
Thumbs Up
2
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
give your head a shake, miramichi on 30/10/09 12:05:22 PM AST
Advertisement
Advertisement

Search Articles