Letter of the day: North End French elementary school is badly needed

Published Monday October 26th, 2009
D8

To The Editor :

It is with grave concern and utter disbelief that I read the Oct. 21 editorial of your newspaper. Let's get directly to the point.

In a very subtle way, it is suggested that the francophone community (School District 1), which is in dire need of a new school in the north end of the city because of critical overcrowding issues, should settle for space left over in an another inner school (School District 2) or again in a school recently closed in this same district. If the empty spaces in these English schools are available, should the District 2 plans for a new school in the north end be cancelled and therefore rezoning of routes be done to send students to these available spaces?

To have such an editorial published just days after a press release from a group of parents asking for a French school to better accommodate students in an area served by three English schools is either due to a complete ignorance of the facts or again by an attempt to treat the francophone community in this city as second class citizens. I shudder to believe this second position and so I will concentrate in supplying you with the facts to rectify this situation, if in fact it is by lack of knowledge on the subject.

First of all, School District 1's geographical territory shares the same territory with seven anglophone districts in very vibrant communities in southern New Brunswick (Fredericton, Oromocto, Saint John, Moncton, Dieppe and Memramcook). It is the only school district in the province that has experienced continual growth since 2002. In fact, we are welcoming 152 new students this year in the 15 schools serving our population of 7,722 students.

The French elementary schools in the City of Moncton have experienced this growth in a very important way.

L'école Saint-Henri being one of the most overcrowded schools in our district has seen its school population grow by 13 per cent in the last three years alone! Please let me inform you of the many magical tricks the school and district administrative staff has had to pull to maintain a good school environment in these conditions. Of the 10 portable classrooms we have added to the Moncton elementary French schools, only two have been placed at Saint-Henri school because of lack of space on the school grounds. In fact, to add one more portable classroom would be to make the school playground practically non-existent.

While awaiting the announcement of a new school, we have had to combine two groups of students with two teachers in a single classroom. As an example, this year the Grade 2 class shares one classroom space for 35 students. We are certainly grateful to the teachers who willingly accept this pedagogical challenge but just how far can we go?

With a library much smaller than the norms and very difficult cafeteria schedules, we believe that District 1's priority in claiming a school in Moncton's booming north end is not only justified, but critical.

Moreover, a recent study has shown that more than 25 per cent of parents who have a right to French schools in that specific area send their children to the English schools that are present in that zone.

Is it not a blatant statement that the French populations who chose to live in our urban areas are much more threatened by assimilation? Should we not do everything in our power to halt this menace and thus continue to grow by respecting both linguistic communities?

In recent years, the City of Moncton has done a lot to respect the English and French duality. I am convinced that these initiatives have contributed immensely to the City's economic, cultural and social standings. Our daily English newspaper should adopt this attitude to continue to boost Moncton's great living environment.

Ernest Thibodeau,

Président

Conseil d'éducation

District scolaire 1

Dieppe

 

Comments (42)

All comments are subject to the site Terms of Use. For a full commenting tutorial click here.

Our editorial team relies on filtering technology and our visitor community to identify inappropriate comments. In the event that a site user has submitted offensive content that has evaded our filter, please select the option to Flag As Inappropriate presented within the comment. Thank you for helping to keep this site clean.

Dump the dual school district system. This would save money, create better facilities for everyone, and actually promote bilingualism and relations between French and English children. But no, Canadians apparently feel separation is better, what opening all black and all boy schools in Ontario (not to mention Catholic school boards) and here instead of having French and English children together.
15
Thumbs Up
7
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Doesn't Matter, Moncton on 26/10/09 12:17:10 PM AST
Why is it that every time we hear from the francophone community in the T&T and elsewhere, there is aways a sense of paranoia? Somebody or something is out to get them. They are being discriminated against, the English are getting better and more schools, the french language is in danger, assimilation, etc, etc. The only menace here is Mr. Thibodeau who has the typical "me first" "we deserve better" attitude.

I would dare say that all schools have had to improvise. Mr. Thibodeau should visit the elementary school in East Riverview to see a desperate situation. How they make things work there is beyond me.
15
Thumbs Up
7
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Halsey T., Riverview on 26/10/09 12:21:22 PM AST
DM - just because you disagree with something doesn't make you right and others wrong. There are reasons why these structures and organisations exist and in some cases should continue to exist. For example, a person who wants to raise their children with a strong catholic faith has no choice but to send them to a catholic school, since public schools are essentially "faith-free" (rightfully so). It's called personal choice - if the population through their votes or through their own money choose to send their kids to be schooled within the confines of their faith, how does that impact you?

I don't disagree with the notion of 1 set of school boards, but I totally disagree with combining schools. Although the pie-in-the-sky notion that this would make people "more" bilingual is a lofty goal, the reality is that Frencophones would just assimilate because the MAJORITY would be English. I'm not sure what's hard to understand here....
4
Thumbs Up
6
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
a-n-o-n-y-m-o-u-s m-e, Moncton on 26/10/09 07:32:08 PM AST
And as for Halsey T. - let's answer a question with a question. Why is it that the only time you're complaining about people asking for stuff (i.e. schools) is when it's francophones are asking for them? It's OK for the Riverview parents to ask for a new school (and the newspaper never suggest they be moved to another ancient building that's just renovated), but, according to you, it's not OK for francophone parents to do the same? Mr. Theriault is doing his job - advocating for the people he represents. Just as I would expect, and RESPECT, the Riverview principal, parents and associated school board to advocate on their kids behalf. It's not about "we deserve better", it's about we deserve the same - nothing more, nothing less.
6
Thumbs Up
6
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
a-n-o-n-y-m-o-u-s m-e, Moncton on 26/10/09 07:43:27 PM AST
Furthermore, as for being paranoid, the reason you might sense this is that we know there are some people like you and DM out there, who would love nothing better than to return to the ancient system of an English only world in NB. Luckily it would be political suicide for anyone to consider going through the very arduous steps of trying to roll back our language rights. Not to mention that the MAJORITY actually support equal language rights in this province and country. Having said this, we still need the Mr. Thibodeau's of the world to represent and advocate for one of the two official linguistic communities. Just like we need strong voices on the English side who respect the "other side", but just want what's best for their linguistic community. Sounds pretty simple to me....
5
Thumbs Up
5
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
a-n-o-n-y-m-o-u-s m-e, Moncton on 26/10/09 07:50:02 PM AST
What part of my post said I wanted an English NB? I said to promote bilingualism and relations between French and English children. I am bilingual (actually multilingual, which is almost definitely more than you can say). I suggest you are the paranoid one here, seeing hate and conspiracy where there is none. I can object to an inefficient dual school system and not be anti-French. I can object to an all black or boy school and not be racist or sexist. Your comments are asinine. I'm curious though since you care so much about linguistic minorities, what about language rights for Natives, or any of the other minorities coming in (which will only grow)? Oh yeah, the only minority you care about is the Acadian one.

The rest of your posts are even more illogical and deserve no retort.
5
Thumbs Up
5
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Doesn't Matter, Moncton on 26/10/09 08:33:20 PM AST


"assimilation... Should we not do everything in our power to halt this menace "

If assimilation is a menace, then so is bilingualism, and must be halted.
6
Thumbs Up
4
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Richard P., Moncton on 26/10/09 09:03:24 PM AST
This is not a language question.It is an educational question. The only eleentary french school in Moncton IS sT. Henri school and it has more portable classrooms than classes in the school. A new French elementary school is badly needed. If a new school is needed in Riverview, then I am all for it. But it should not be one or another but according to the needs.
6
Thumbs Up
0
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
J. R, Moncton, NB on 26/10/09 09:17:31 PM AST
DM - You're right, your first post on this article didn't blatantly talk about your hatrid for language equality within our province and country. I can admit to that - no problem.

My one-liner was more in response to all the other stuff you've written on these boards describing how right you think the ASNB group and COR party are, and how wrong Off. bilingualism is.... Don't bother asking me to provide quotes and links because I've long since deleted those bookmarks, but we both know that I'm right - even if you'll never admit it.

And finally, even though you constantly deflect the subject to immigrants on every official language debate (so as to never admit your hatrid of OL), I'm not falling for it. Continue to call me names like a 2 year old (ironic that I've seen you whine many a time on the name calling issue), continue to deflect, continue to hate, but just don't think that no one is noticing - that's all.
5
Thumbs Up
3
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
a-n-o-n-y-m-o-u-s m-e, Moncton on 26/10/09 10:04:54 PM AST
By the way, I love how the only posts that are illogical - EVER - are the ones that disagree with you....that's funny.
4
Thumbs Up
3
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
a-n-o-n-y-m-o-u-s m-e, Moncton on 26/10/09 10:06:48 PM AST
Advertisement
Advertisement

Search Articles